To-Review List

Summary:

A relatively updated list of comics that we have decided should be reviewed.

page 1 of 3123next »

To-Review List

Evilkritter 10 Jul 2011 06:12

Comics currently being considered for reviewing. This list will err on the side of review it now bitch. Check out any that catch your interest, we need reviewers. When you finish a review, please post in this thread to notify the general populace, or link it off of the site index yourself.

Initial listing courtesy of DrShaym.

Moon over June - Pornographically offensive, among other things.

The FAN - Being reviewed. Very slowly.

Bridges - I think we all decided that this was bad, but I suggested that we wait until it's at least a year old.

Teachers Pet - I think we're all in agreement that this should be reviewed.

Eerie Cuties - The thread kind of got derailed into a discussion over gay discrimination and psychiatry and nobody really decided if it should be reviewed or not.

Everyday Grind - The other one I suggested. BTIssac was the only one who replied and nobody else expressed any interest.

US Angel Corps - This was a long thread and I think everyone agreed that it should be reviewed, but there was no decision regarding who should review it.

Bittersweet Candy Bowl - ApostleTalon said he would write the review for this one, but has yet to do so. That was about three weeks ago, and in a thread that was started in August of 2010, and hasn't been brought up since.

Farewell Feeling - This thread stopped after three posts.

BTIsaac is reviewing - The Wotch: CHEER! - The thread got derailed into a discussion about whether or not there's anything inherently wrong with animu art style.

Mushroom Go - No consensus was reached.

The Other Grey Meat - The thread didn't go anywhere.

The End of Things - I think everyone who posted in this thread decided that it wasn't bad enough.

Triquetra Cats - BTIsaac says this is part of The Wotch canon. New site, link to the comic is here.

My life with Fel - This thread got derailed into a discussion about sexism.

Mad Science is working on it-Evon - This thread didn't get far, but the general consensus was that this comic is bad.

Moon Daughters - This thread only has three posts. No consensus was reached.

LOLsketch - Everybody who posted hates it, but nobody volunteered to review it.

Bob the Angry Flower - Thread ended after three posts.

Knighthood - MacarovJAC suggested this one but got no replies.

Namir Deiter - Lame furry Slice of Life that has been going on way to long for how little improvement the comic has shown.

The Little Merman - Low priority, kind of lame but not terrible.

Evilkritter is working on a review - The FAN - Because BTIsaac is some kind of masochist.

Last edited on 09 Aug 2011 16:59 by Evilkritter + Show more

Re: To-Review List

The Luigiian 10 Jul 2011 06:59

Thanks for the update EvilKritter and DrShaym.

Goddamn, every time I see US Angel Corps there's another bit of horror that catches my eye. It's like a trainwreck where people are jumping out of the train engulfed in flames, and every time you think everyone's gotten out another dozen pop out and fall to the ground writhing in agony.

It's like the Hindenburg disaster.

It's like a graphic-novel version of the Holocaust.

It's like goddamn I hate this comic and I want to call it for review so goddamn bad but I feel like it would be wrong to deprive someone else of the joy of ripping Cheung a new asshole and I don't know if it's long enough for me to really get my hate-vibes going. Plus I might say something positive about the art which would make me hate myself.

Teacher's Pet gives me strong Chris-Chan vibes btw.

Re: To-Review List

DrShaym 10 Jul 2011 21:38

I can write a review for Angel Corps. I haven't been active here lately because I've been really tired from doing video shoots.

Re: To-Review List

neallyriceguy 13 Jul 2011 20:32

The really scary thing is that it's apparently made by two people.

That's even more insulting to those authors, knowing that their combined efforts are roughly equivalent to one autistic manchild.

And since I clearly haven't been doing anything 'round here lately, I'll pitch in for a review, 'cept the only ones I've fully read are Mushroom Go and Eerie Cuties.

Re: To-Review List

HachiSanju 15 Jul 2011 08:00

Well this is my first post here, so hello!

Anyway unexpected entrance aside, since there are so many comics to take on, I thought maybe I'd try my hand at reviewing Knighthood. I haven't written any reviews here before so it might not be the most spectacular review ever, but I'm sure I can provide a product!

Re: To-Review List

DrShaym 15 Jul 2011 08:45

Here's your first reply.

Re: To-Review List

Mad Science 10 Jul 2011 18:24

I'm currently out of town, but I should have time for Evon by next week.

Re: To-Review List

MakarovJAC 12 Jul 2011 16:53

I'll be reviewing Life with Fel by next weekend. By the way, tell me how to do the image trick for reviews.

Re: To-Review List

DrShaym 12 Jul 2011 23:29

To upload an image directly to the server, go to the bottom of the page where it says "page revision", "Edit", "History", etc., and click on "Files". A section will open up underneath it with a link that says "Upload a file from your computer". Click on it, and the "file upload" section will appear. Click on the "Select Files" button to browse your computer for the desired image.

Once the image is uploaded, use this source code to insert it: http://oi53.tinypic.com/4t6mo5.jpg
Where it says "GodsStoryArt.JPG", that will be the name of your own image.

You can also use the "Insert Image Wizard" (the green button with the sparkle) for help with alignment and resizing.

To insert an image with a caption and a border, use this code: http://oi56.tinypic.com/i6z8kw.jpg
Where it says "350px", that denotes how wide the image will appear on the website. The text between the double carots (^^) is the caption. Again, where it says "JesusGetsRaped.JPG", that will be your own file.

Alternatively, you can embed an image hosted on another website. Use this code: http://oi56.tinypic.com/11vo56e.jpg
Where it says the URL, you put the URL of the image you wish to embed. Keep in mind that if the host site ever shuts down or deletes the image, the image will no longer be visible in the review.

Last edited on 12 Jul 2011 23:32 by DrShaym + Show more

Re: To-Review List

BTIsaac 12 Jul 2011 18:01

On the topic of updates
- Triquetra Cats is still updating, it just moved to a new site.
- I'm currently going through Cheer, and will be reviewing it some time in the near future.
- There was no real decision on US Angel Corps, most of the argument consisted of personal attacks against the author.
- The FAN seems to be missing from this list. I know Ivynn called it, but that was months ago.

Re: To-Review List

MakarovJAC 12 Jul 2011 21:49

You're simply looking for trouble, doesn't it? Ivynn hasn't show up in a while and you still on the same? You know what I'm doing your review if you want it so much. I'll make it this weekend right after I make MY Life with Fel's review.

Happy now?

Re: To-Review List

BTIsaac 13 Jul 2011 09:24

I'm not looking for trouble, I'm just saying it was missing from the list.

Re: To-Review List

The Luigiian 14 Jul 2011 07:59

Dude, I don't get you man. You say you're not "looking for trouble", but seriously, I would like to point out that you're looking for critique on a website called "the bad webcomics wiki" which is specifically designed to review bad webcomics and you're saying you want us to post a review of your webcomic.

You've done some decent reviews, and you're usually OK, if oftentimes a little annoying, but are you a masochist or some shit? I mean, this is like a furry going onto the Something Awful forums asking them to give him some pointers on fursuit design.

Re: To-Review List

BTIsaac 14 Jul 2011 09:35

No. But any improvement that was made during the course of the third chapter, was due to feedback from 910CMX. After the third chapter was complete I stopped receiving any feedback at all, apart from one reader who tends to comment on a few of the pages, and I'm basically flying blind. Makarov already gave me some advice regarding a few details and I'm working on fixing them, but unless I'm told what I'm doing wrong, it's very unlikely I'll discover it on my own any time soon.

That said, I'm not really 'asking' for it, even though it would be helpful, I'm simply pointing out that even though it was previously pinned, it doesn't seem to show up on this current list - along with other details regarding some other comics that DO appear on ths list, but their notes need to be adjusted.

Re: To-Review List

MakarovJAC 14 Jul 2011 13:13

ONe last thing. Dude, we're not a show & tell site. We make criticism. An sometimes, criticism can get harsh. But it doesnt mean WE contact Chalo-fap or Jay Naylor to tell them they're doing right or wrong at certain stuff. We just criticize. That's what a review is, the points why we consider they makes it a BAD WEBCOMIC. If you want us to take you by the hand and croos the street for you, it's an issue. We don't do that.

If you want help ask for it, but don't go anywhere getting into something you cant get out off. Remeber, reviews here are permanet (or until the next succesful hacker) and the only changes we make on them are on the "end date".

Last edited on 14 Jul 2011 13:15 by MakarovJAC + Show more

Re: To-Review List

BTIsaac 14 Jul 2011 18:14

On the end date, or any time the existing review grows outdated - I presume that's what you meant to say. ;)

Don't presume I don't already know anything you said. I know what I'm talking about, now can we take this discussion to the relevant thread you started? I don't want a repeat incident of what happened on the My Life With Fel discussion.

Re: To-Review List

Ivynn 18 Jul 2011 01:27

I'm still here, just lurking every other day. ;)

But I'm going to have to give up on writing any reviews. Too much going on for me to invest the time, sorry guys!

Re: To-Review List

Mad Science 14 Jul 2011 06:37

Evon is now in progress. I'll see how this pans out.

Re: To-Review List

BTIsaac 15 Jul 2011 08:52

You forgot to update the Cheer section. I'm currently planning on doing a review for that one.

Re: To-Review List

thedude86 18 Jul 2011 21:31

Sorry for the derailment on the Eerie Cuties thread. I think it should certainly be reviewed. I think there`s sufficient enough arguments to take criticism of the comic from to make a full review.

Re: To-Review List

oddguy 09 Aug 2011 17:14

it makes me sad to see BCB on here… i used to love this comic.
it was probably the first comic iv read,iv been following it since the day it started and talking with it's creator on a regular basis. (up until recently.)
but even i cant ignore how bad it's gotten.
and i do mean "gotten". it used to have some redeeming qualities and the person writing it was honestly bent on improving the bad parts.

but,like with most webcomics,as it became more popular and lucrative the quality dropped.
i still have a warm spot in my heart for this comic though… whoever reviews this,be nice.

about LOLsketch… i actually started that thread,but now that i think about it… what is there to review ?
it's a crappy C&H knockoff by someone who wouldn't know humor if it fucked him in the ass.

anyway,id love to review any of these if someone agrees to look over what i wrote and fix some of the grammar and punctuation.
(english not my first language.)

Re: To-Review List

MakarovJAC 25 Aug 2011 05:28

Do it. Luig in a recent topic proclaimed we're free to review whatever we want as long it passes consensus and the review sticks to the rules (don't ask me for them). No questions asked.

Re: To-Review List

DrShaym 11 Aug 2011 08:10

I'm updating the list of comics that either need to be reviewed or are still pending a decision over whether or not to review them.

Moon over June (review up)
The FAN
Bridges
Teachers Pet (review up)
Eerie Cuties
Everyday Grind
US Angel Corps (review up)
Bittersweet Candy Bowl (review up)
Farewell Feeling
The Wotch: CHEER! (review under construction by BTIsaac) (BTIssac got banned before he could finish it)
Mushroom Go
The Other Grey Meat
The End of Things
Triquetra Cats
My life with Fel (review up)
Evon (Mad Science is working on it)
Moon Daughters
LOLsketch (review up)
Bob the Angry Flower
Knighthood (Gryphoneer is working on it)
Namir Deiter
The Little Merman
The FAN (Evilkritter is working on it)
So... You're a Cartoonist? (review up)
Olympic Dames
LeetStreet Boys
Drips-n'-Dregs
Paradox (MakarovJAC says he's working on it)
Elwood
Stalag '99
The Way to Your Heart
Jack (not this Jack, but a different one) (review up)
God Hates Bambi (this thread also mentions Blood Bound, but that comic no longer exists) (review up)
Bridgette's Belly (once reviewed by EmmaMonster, but the review is gone now)
No Cash Value
Ginger's Bread
Bored and Evil (once reviewed by Truthfulpietro but then lost, he is now rewriting it) (review up)
Hejibits
Otaku-No-Yen (review up)
Jam and the Solutions
Between Failures
B.I.T.C.H. Squad
Drinking Peaches
Get Your War On
Girl Genius
Elftor (review up)
Panthera
Perki Goth/Candi Raver (review up)
Comics in Disguise
Last Res0rt (I started a new thread because I couldn't find the original, which may be over a year old)
Nikki Sprite
Anhedonia Blue (same thread as Nikki Sprite)
Dare Sensei (review up)
Press Start to Play
Anathema
Ask Altair
Ansem Retort
Elle and the Others
Greg
Closetcoon (Long Tom is working on this one)
21st Century Fox
Kawaii Otaku Daigaku
Dume
Homestuck

51 in total. Some of these threads go back to January of 2010.

Last edited on 03 Feb 2012 23:58 by DrShaym + Show more

Re: To-Review List

neallyriceguy 22 Sep 2011 05:51

Wait a minute… "Dare Sensei"? Why the hell did I not notice this desecration?!

As someone who likes Doctor Who and someone who looks down upon the weeaboo occultists, I need to review this one. Because this time, it's personal.

Last edited on 22 Sep 2011 05:58 by neallyriceguy + Show more

Re: To-Review List

FairyinBoots 24 Nov 2011 02:18

Does anybody mind if I write a review on Ansem Retort? I checked the topic, and no one has posted on it since 2010.

Re: To-Review List

DrShaym 21 Aug 2011 11:00

Maybe we should have a page linked in the sidebar where comics pending reviews are listed, and then removed once reviews are made. Maybe we should also have a "newest reviews" section.

page 1 of 3123next »