This could potentially be our new comics rating system, based on the following image:
Here's the idea:= Fucking terrible. The absolute worst there is.
[p]= Okay/Just mediocre. It's not gut-wrenchingly bad but nor is it brilliant.
[p]Fairly good. Inspires some good feelings.
[p]= Very good. It's at the top of its genre, has perhaps inspired a few knockoffs, and its fanbase actually has a reason to like it.
We might be able to give a rating to art, story, characters, and plot separately, and then give an overall rating based on these things.
What say you?
Edit: This is my first result. See what you think. (I changed plot to "Miscellaneous Details")